CO129-403 - Governor Sir May Acting Governor Claud Severn - 1913 [8-10] — Page 307

305

end i odanjai jail and to yjub end ei ti tant welo si wal end "eiv

oj dajuua jnied si noisiberdre eaquw nostaq bajoivnoo в to 9830 and Jauit abnit en ¿ und bebivunq noijibuidxe Tol monteg tand JimmOD où bra ritiw baliquoo need svari val noitibentre and lo snoitegildo boaist ad of adsoiwį, nɔt to selq s as rows ancijaeup legal evəŞİ abrow Tanto ni ;auq7o) asedali to】 moisaoil,që ne no nosieq and yd sin to atimil edt ebiejuo emg asri bralezak .ni tant amint I gnivad of noiði, ba ni LIs da dnioq sod anibiɔeb ni noitoibsizį,

•Y4300TW Jnioq edt bebiseb

of aa aaita eono Ja parquou to „noijaeup ent ed bluoris aqste railtzot yus dont modeiw Jnenutrevod Birit veritariw izontu.. aejatë baðinu an: Jadt Iduob on sved I ;radtam and mi naxod doir aqaja rendist yua exet of tre...tevʊð Bidd aвetų lliw esİJ- .nam sing to Tebitiwa and niaddo bus yet of slainnoq lla da ed you sind ni doanei suve ja yllarwey avoir ya bensstore ybsería ovan I pretensed and to dodaqaeli jaad siid to waiv ni tant lost I jud elit JUO VTIJO OJ "worsabae oluoda ow Jadd tağın yino si ti,etatë To (18▼ Juď .18`oq wo to Jeawu edt of enoitgildo y serî wo -ɣna ob od sluinsoq si ti raudonw oj sa asins snoijseup Jluvillib -ei,a odt zniwaiver no? taixe anaou Jew of as bis Stow quint- ylintutan dotuw se88600tų esuit era exalt wolf .noiaioeb a'ətənda tøywał a od TX:00

[seqgA (8)

atlobnad (d)

ejsijaizal Tendons exoted ayibʊsoorq diseri (0)

•Yĺajmzayaa sa890oung sordid amend sitiw Ineb Iliw I bas Judd aaya beitsidan me I,(s) at binger ntiv

.Isoqyn oa si stadi

vytlvoittib yısnimilonq a ai exent (d) of binger ativ

guitquetta joemvievo) odt ni idatmomtuarw Jon Bi revewodi do żdw

Leivibuls to noitisog and Jud ;resitło two ati sunabrim od

Oviduos! To eviJawaindub▲ us to tacit as essen add ton at rasitto

Boijuojdo that, yno sú od su od mesa Jon Boob exerit brus zeofilo

may adi to ono Janinge allusius a tot eniyi ya mwonɔ end of

ylojarnisa su od even IIiw yidawɛety revewori ouw zetarjaiga..

represented and whose costs I suppose will have to be paid by the

Government. A more serious difficulty however exists in the fact

that it is difficult to see exactly what form the Landais should

take; and I can only sugest that if these Mandaue proceedings are

authorized, an application in the first instance should be made to

Mr. Hazeland to carry out the terms of the Governor's requisition

according to lay and in the event of his refusal (which we may

anticipate) then to the Full Court asking for an order against him

calling upon him to hear and determine the matter according to law.

Of course one will be met with two arguments and two serious

arguments; the first of which is that this procedure forms a means of directly traversing the judicial discretion of the Magistrate which is not given under the law and secondly that the Magistrate

has already decided the case according to the best of his judg-

-ment.

With regard to (c) we are confronted with still greater difficulties; Mr. Hazeland is the Senior Magistrate and it can hardly be expected that if we apply to a Junior Eagistrate, such Junier Magistrate will disagree with his Senior colleague; even to apply to another Magistrate would give the proceedings the air of persecution and if another Magistrate decided differently from Mr. Hazeland, it would probably be said that the Government had instructed him as to the decision which he should give; whilst to appoint a Special Magistrate for this particular case would again give rise to even more unfavourable comment. It is however perhaps even doubtful whether if application was made to another Magistrate it might not successfully be pleaded that the matter had already been disposed of.

5. From the above observations you will see that I am at a loss to suggest any other course save that of the Mandamus and even in that course I feel no very great confidence; the difficulty being firstly to persuade the Full Court to give a decision on an academic point which the order for their mandamus if granted could hardly specifically refer to. In other words unless one could devise some form of order under which the Full Court would call